Freeze Response (part 2): Thawing Our Frozenness
Freezing is a kind of banishment of experience to the non-conscious realm.
Webster includes a definition of freeze as “to make unavailable for current use.” This feels chillingly true for nervous system freeze.
Freeze can refer to a global disconnection, as in shock where we are dissociated and there is a stillness/silence in our inner world.
It can also refer to the absence of emotion where emotion is appropriate, or the inability to sense the sensations of our emotions or areas of our bodies.
Freeze can feel like being locked out of feeling and living a life of the mind in thoughts, judgements, stories.
When freeze is shared, like in the insidious aftermath of cultural or ancestral/family trauma, the residue of absence in us may not even be perceived [by others in our lives].
Part of the life preserving function of freeze is that we are able to disconnect from sensing some dissonant experience or dimension in ourselves.
The ‘but’ here is that this part of ourselves is no longer available to inform us or to live.
Conscious awareness no longer has access to the felt experience of the pain, fear, anger, of feeling alone in the experiences that were too much to be with, too much to include in our sense of self.
The territory of freeze can be likened to once cleared and inhabited land that has returned to forest, vines, jungle.
Reclaiming this land is the territory of healing - returning to wholeness.
In the process of return, when we make contact with inner frozen, offline places, we can feel disoriented, agitated, afraid, angry…
Because what gets frozen or dis-inhabited are the places in us that have not experienced welcome in the context of relationship, the thawing or re-inhabiting/reclaiming process needs the warmth and responsiveness of attuned connection - an experience of accompaniment that communicates safety, builds trust, follows, rewires the felt experience of vulnerability as opportunity for longed for connection and understanding.
This is a radical and healing shift from the earlier freezing experience of aloneness, shame, disconnection in the felt sense of vulnerability.
Relational attunement and warmth invite sensing and internal movement/process which are the antithesis of freeze. And because an early experience of threat is encoded with the vulnerability in the frozenness, the movement, sensations, feelings, emotions may well trigger a reflexive protective response in us.
If we recognize these protective responses as data letting us know we are contacting an un-integrated part of ourselves, we may be able to respond compassionately.
Sometimes when there is pervasive absence and threat in our early environment, the conditioned protection from relational vulnerability can seem iron clad. This was wisdom back then and now creates a sense of aloneness that follows us everywhere.
Because this once wise and now limiting conditioning is held deep below consciousness, in implicit or procedural memory, modalities like the Safe and Sound Protocol from Dr Stephen Porges which work below conscious awareness can be powerful in reconditioning the deep brain’s early protective conditioning.
This modality interfaces with the deep brain through filtered sound designed specifically to recalibrate the default protective response to human presence and allows a much more meaningful quality of internal and external relating than what was initially set - ‘human presence as threat’ conditioning.
When our nervous system is developing, if we are faced with the dilemma of staying with our own authentic experience, needs and feelings that threaten the capacity of our relational network to stay in connection with us, our physiology dictates that we anesthetize or tense around our experience to maintain relational okayness…
In other words, it’s not a conscious choice to leave ourselves, it’s a kind of biological imperative - part of being human.
Our nervous systems run a negativity bias to help us survive - prioritizing attention to potential threat over what is nourishing, comfortable or neutral. This negativity bias is strengthened when there is a foundational deficit in the meeting of needs and feelings in our early development.
In this environment, the deep brain’s default response to challenge orients to shouldering, enduring, surviving challenge through our own efforts often with oblivion to whether we have the resources or energetic capacity to meet these challenges on our own. This is because our early survival depended in part on that oblivion [freeze].
Often, we will not even notice the unsustainable orientation to operate beyond our capacity until our energetic reserves become depleted.
Noticing that we are caught in a negativity bias can help us recognize that we are in need of some nervous system reconditioning! That life could feel easier, more connected, more joyful.
By contrast, in an early environment where needs and feelings are perceived and responded to with care by caregivers [This is known as a resource rich environment for caregivers and their young.], the deep brain orients to potential support, connection, resource with which to move through challenges. In these early environments, we become more connected, related, resilient …. We feel supported and inextricably part of something bigger than ourselves.
In the absence of that attuned responsiveness, we learn to override our authentic experience, to act ‘okay’ in not ‘okay’ situations.
We may not even be able to recognize that we are not ‘okay’.
We respond “I’m good.” or “I’m fine.” when the truth is “I’m overwhelmed.” or “I’m worried.”
We feel flat, bored, unmotivated, disconnected. This is freeze.
In the persistence of relational absence (which, by the way, is pervasive in modern culture) what is painful (without the responsive care of others) becomes anesthetized.
The vulnerable places in us that might have allowed more meaningful connection with others, have lost or never developed a sense of belonging in relationship - internally and inter-personally. They no longer have ‘cell reception’, are walled off for a protection that leads to a sense of emptiness and aloneness.
Part of developing a healing presence lies in the shift of identity and behavior from a negativity bias toward a resource bias - not through effort but by learning to open to and orient to what is actually available in the way of connection and support right now.
Part of what can feel confounding in this endeavor is that when we make contact with some dimension of our experience that needed to get paused/postponed for later processing, we can feel pulled back into the overwhelm, disorientation…
In learning to keep our anchor, and thus sense of self, in relational resource and just meeting the periphery of the discomfort of emotion or sensation, the presence/support of another (what was missing initially) can be essential.
Slowing down the process, and bringing conscious awareness into connection with the embodied experience as we sense, brings in more of what was missing that required the disconnection from our experience back then. This healing is a process of attunement and titration and requires kind patience and compassion.
In this process, we begin to shift from identifying with the painful experiences, or sensing these experiences as threats that need to be gotten rid of, and instead shift into becoming the loving presence these parts of us needed and did not experience. In this process, the thawing and healing begin.
A welcoming attuned therapeutic or group relational field can support the thawing of what lacked relational inclusion in our earlier experience and help us tolerate the feelings and sensations of those earlier experiences coming back into life and feeling. This tolerance comes through accompaniment - a warmer and much bigger set of processing units - our more mature nervous system and connection to caring others digesting with us instead of the overwhelm of experiencing all alone.
To have a healing or thawing experience as these sensations come back online requires the presence of the missing elements from the earlier time, namely relational attunement, welcome, inclusion, a sense of agency, responsiveness and more time and space for the process.
The sensing of what was too much, back then becomes tolerable now as we make the felt resource greater than the felt challenge
In this way, the thawing of the aliveness that had to be numbed [and not felt as a support to managing overwhelm back then in the interest of our relational survival] returns to us and to life.
Becoming part of a new relational field or network where the intention is building presence in ourselves to tolerate and eventually welcome more of our experience is a profound support to healing - not only returning to wholeness in ourselves but to wholeness as relational beings in community.
Engaging in this kind of thawing process also creates an interruption of the earlier conditioned patterning. To experience warm connection with the emotions or sensations of tensing, numbness and aloneness creates a re-informative dissonance with the old lived experience of feeling unwelcomed and not okay with others just as we were.
Eventually we, with our developing relational network, are able to hold these formerly isolated parts of ourselves in an orb of love that is bigger and extends beyond what is crimped, contracted, numbed. And what we once felt as a threat to our well being, can be recognized as our lost life force longing to return to the flow of our lives.
This is truly countercultural and revolutionary - a way of reclaiming our life energy, our sense of meaningful connection and our sense of power!